Stylos is the blog of Jeff Riddle, a Reformed Baptist Pastor in North Garden, Virginia. The title "Stylos" is the Greek word for pillar. In 1 Timothy 3:15 Paul urges his readers to consider "how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar (stylos) and ground of the truth." Image (left side): Decorative urn with title for the book of Acts in Codex Alexandrinus.
Tuesday, December 14, 2021
Dr. Masters' Conference Introduction & Owen Book Comments
Saturday, December 11, 2021
WM 217: Rejoinder to Hixson on the TR and "Getting the Data Right"
Notes for WM 217:
I’m just getting back in the groove after a recent trip to London where I was honored to speak in the “Day of Special Studies” for the School of Theology at the Metropolitan Tabernacle Church, where on Saturday, November 27, 2021 I gave three lectures on the theme “The War Against An Authentic Biblical Text,” which are now posted to my WM channel (find links here).
While still in England, I was made aware of a
blog post that appeared on the Evangelical Textual Criticism blog on
December 1, 2021, which offered a critique of a statement, taken out of context,
from a recent podcast interview I had done with Dwayne Green.
In this episode I want to offer a rejoinder to this blog post
and what I believe are its misrepresentations regarding my point on the unity
of the readings found in the classic printed Protestant editions of the TR.
Background:
Here is a bit of the background: I did an interview via Zoom with
Dwayne Green, a Pentecostal Pastor from Canada, back on November 11, 2021. I
think we spoke for nearly two hours.
He then took the video material, edited it (according to the
sometimes jumpy and humorous style he uses in his blogcast), and he released
the interview in three segments over several days.
The third of those videos was posted on November 29, 2021 and
was titled “Which TR does the Traditional Text Use?”
Just two days after the release of that third video (December
1, 2021), Elijah Hixson, associate pastor of the Fireside Fellowship Church in
Kingston, TN, posted
a “longish post” (as he put it) on the Evangelical Textual Criticism blog,
responding to a statement, taken out of context, which I had made in that video
with respect to the so-called “Which TR?” objection.
His post was titled, “On the Comma Johanneum, ‘Which TR?’ and working from inadequate data.”
Some general things I found interesting about Hixson’s post:
There were a couple of rather interesting things overall about
Pastor Hixson’s post.
First, Pastor Hixson begins by telling his readers that he
did this post “only because I care about data and getting it right.” He provides
a link to the podcast interview, but he only cites one statement from me in the
written article (and even that was not cited as a direct quotation), out of
context, and, oddly enough, never bothers directly to mention my name or to
offer any analysis for the background for the conversation.
This reminds me of the way a certain Popular Internet
Apologist (PIA) used to respond to my material on his podcast. Yes, I get the
irony of the fact that I did not mention the PIA’s name in the previous
sentence.
Wouldn’t it make sense for someone who wants to “get the data
right” to be clear about whose work he’s critiquing?
Pastor Hixson also makes an odd reference later to another
anonymous “TR Advocate” whom he accuses of committing a supposed logical
fallacy (the “True Scotsman”) argument. This may also be a reference to yours
truly, but I’m not sure, because Pastor Hixson provides no name, reference, or
context for this charge.
My sense is that by this comment Pastor Hixson may be attempting
to respond preemptively to the objection he knows I will raise against his misrepresentation
of my quoted statement. Namely, he knows that that my statement was with
respect to all the classic, mature, Protestant printed editions, that they
contain Matthew 6:13b, Mark 16:9-20, John 7:53—8:11, Acts 8:37, and 1 John
5:7b-8a—but more on this later.
Second, those in the TR community are well familiar with
Pastor Hixson and his frequent offers of online “help,” because he only cares
“about the data and getting it right.” I
remember a conversation I had with one TR advocate a few years ago who noted
that Pastor Hixson seems to be a ubiquitous presence on all social media sites
dedicated to textual criticism and he’s often quick to offer his brand of neutral “corrections” to anyone promoting
the traditional text. Yes, he is quite a disinterested and objective observer
of these things.
Third, it is interesting that Pastor Hixson is apparently now
listening to video and audio podcasts (given that he linked the video interview
with Dwayne Green and made this “longish post” on my comments, taken out of
context, from it). This is interesting, because in past online interactions
with Pastor Hixson, when I suggested he listen to my WM podcast to understand
statements I had made in context, he responded that he always preferred written
content and never listened to podcasts or watched online videos, because he
found these hard to engage his restless and active mind. I guess his opinion and
practices on podcasts and videos has changed.
Now, let’s get down to the nitty gritty of his objections,
and you can judge for yourself whether he “got the data right.”
What was my contested statement?
So, what was the one statement from the roughly two hours of
conversation that I had with Dwayne Green to which Pastor Hixson takes
exception in his article. It was this one, which I will try to cite verbatim
from the recording:
“All of those printed editions of the TR included Mark
16:9-20; all of them included John 7:53—8:11; all of them included the doxology
of the Lord’s Prayer (Matthew 6:13b); all of them included the Ethiopian eunuch’s
confession in Acts 8:37; all of them included the Comma Johanneum (1 John
5:7-8), so the differences between them are relatively minor….”
What was Hixson’s assessment?
Pastor Hixson declares, “that statement simply is not true.”
He then proceeded to cite several early printed editions
of the Greek NT that do not include the doxology of Matthew 6:13b (the Complutensian
Polyglot), the Ethiopian eunuch’s confession (the Complutensian Polyglot), or
the CJ (Erasmus’ first two editions [1516, 1519], the Aldine [1518], Gerbellius’
edition [1521], Köpfel’s edition [1524], and Colinaeus’
edition [1534]).
He also makes a reference to the fact that the CJ did not
appear in the first edition of Luther’s German NT, since he followed the second
edition of Erasmus (1519), and to the fact that the CJ appears in “brackets in
smaller type” in an English translation, the Matthew’s Bible (1537).
The flaw in Hixson’s critique:
The basic flaw in Pastor Hixson’s critique of my statement is
his assumption of what I meant by “the printed editions of the TR.”
Granted, I should also have been clearer and will try to do
so in the future to avoid any confusion.
By “printed editions of the TR” I was not referring to all
early printed editions of the Greek NT, but specifically to the classic,
mature, Protestant printed editions of the TR, which served as the basis
for the Protestant vernacular translations of the Reformation and Post-Reformation
(Protestant Orthodox) eras.
Another anonymous charge Pastor Hixson levels in his article
is: “Instead of dealing with that question [the ‘Which TR’ objection], some TR
defenders seem to brush it off as irrelevant.”
I’m not sure if he counts me among this anonymous group of “some
TR defenders.”
I did post a
blog article on the topic back in 2019 in response to a “Which TR?”
critique offered by Dirk Jongkind, and I have continued to expand on and
clarify that response in various contexts.
My friend Vince Krivda has also written an extended article
on the topic, titled, “Which
TR?! A Response to Mark Ward’s Critique of Confessional Bibliology.” I’m
sure Pastor Hixson would want to “get the data right” by acknowledging these
responses.
In my aforementioned blogpost, I have tried to offer a confessional
response to the “Which TR?” objection and to clarify what I mean when I appeal
to the printed editions of the TR. Here’s an excerpt from the post as it
currently stands:
First, it is important to point out that there is no single
“perfect” printed edition of the TR. This does not mean, however, that the
various printed editions of the TR taken collectively fail to provide for us a
reasonable and reliable witness to the received text.
At the Text and Canon Conference Jonathan Arnold made mention of the TBS’s helpful “Statement of Doctrine of Holy Scripture” which, for the NT, refers to the received text as “a group of printed texts” adding that “the scope of the Society’s Constitution does not extend to considering the minor variations between the printed editions of the Textus Receptus.”
Second, we should not let the fact that such minor variations exist among the various printed editions of the TR overshadow the fact that those editions are overwhelmingly uniform and, particularly so, with regard to those places where there are major differences with the modern critical text. All the classic Protestant printed editions of the TR, for example, include the doxology of the Lord’s Prayer (Matt 6:13b), the traditional ending of Mark, “the only begotten Son” at John 1:18, the PA, Acts 8:37, “God was manifest in the flesh” at 1 Timothy 3:16, the CJ, etc.
As for the remaining minor variations, each of these, should be evaluated on a case by case basis. If this is done, I believe that most of them will be easily resolved, while only a few will call for more careful deliberation.
I later added:
The editions which should be primarily consulted
are the classic Protestant ones of Stephanus and Beza, based on Erasmus'
foundational work. The Elzevir editions should also be consulted, but with the
understanding that they appeared after most of the translations of the TR had
first been made into the modern languages of Europe.
Given this context, it should be clear that when I made
reference to “all the printed editions of the TR” including the various
passages mentioned, I was not speaking about every early printed editions of
the Greek NT, but the classic, mature, Protestant printed editions of
the TR, as epitomized in those of Stephanus, Beza, and, later, the Elzevirs.
Let me briefly review the six early printed editions of
the Greek NT, which Pastor Hixson cites:
First: The Complutensian Polyglot was a RC edition of the
Greek NT, produced in Spain under the authority of Cardinal Ximenes. It is
hardly surprising then that, following the Latin Vulgate, it did not include
Matthew 6:13b.
Second: The Aldine edition was also produced in a RC context
in Venice in 1518. Luther did not appear before the Diet of Worms until 1521.
It is not a Protestant printed edition of the TR. In addition, its NT followed
the first edition of Erasmus, so it is not an independent witness for the
omission of the CJ.
Third: Pastor Hixson also cites the omission of the CJ from
the first two editions of Erasmus (1516, 1519). Erasmus’ Greek NT was indeed foundational
for the TR, but it was not a Protestant printed edition either. We should also
note that the CJ was included in Erasmus’ third, fourth, and fifth editions (1522,
1527, 1536). The standard for Erasmus’s printed Greek NT should not be the first
two which he later corrected, but the final, corrected, and complete editions,
as affirmed by the Protestant orthodox.
Given his stated emphatic desire, to “get the data right,” surely
Pastor Hixson would not suggest that I did not know that the Erasmus’ first and
second printed editions of the Greek NT omitted the CJ. After all, I published
a scholarly article in 2017 in the PRJ titled “Erasmus
Anecdotes” which discussed extensively the “rash wager” legend related to
the CJ’s inclusion in the third edition of his Greek NT.
Fourth:
As I understand it, Gerbellius was a humanist and not a full-throated Protestant.
My guess is that his edition (1521) was based on the earlier editions of Erasmus,
so it is not an independent example of the omission of the CJ.
Fifth:
Köpfel’s edition (1524) would have appeared in the early
stages of the Reformation, so it was not a mature Protestant edition. I also assume
that like the Gerbellius edition it was likely based on one or both of the first
two editions of Erasmus.
I might add here that Pastor Hixson mentions
Luther’s omission of the CJ in first edition of his German NT, but he concedes
that it was later added to the German Bible, as indeed this reflected the
Protestant consensus.
Sixth: The Colinaeus edition (1534) also could
not possibly be classified as a mature Protestant edition of the TR. This is
another case where I am sure that Pastor Hixon in his zeal to “get the data
right” would not want to overlook the fact that I published a 2017 academic
article, also in the PRJ, titled “John
Calvin and Text Criticism” in which I noted Calvin’s distinct transition from
using the Greek text of Colinaeus in his commentaries and the writings of his
early ministry to making use of the printed TR of Stephanus in this mature
ministry. In my article, I lean heavily on the research of renowned Calvin
scholar T. H. L. Parker, who notes that Colinaeus’ NT was astonishingly “modern”
(see p. 135 in my article) and suggests Calvin made the transition under the
influence of Stephanus. Perhaps Pastor Hixson would accuse Parker of committing
the “True Scotsman” fallacy by concluding that Colinaeus’ Greek NT was not a “true”
Protestant TR!
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the fatal flaw in Pastor Hixson’s
critique of my statement, taken out of context from a podcast conversation, was
his failure to draw a distinction between the early printed editions of the Greek
NT and the classic, mature Protestant editions of the TR. My statement referred
to the latter and not the former.
Pastor Hixson gives great weight in his argument
to a 1999 QR article by G. W. and D. E. Anderson, which also appears on
the TBS website, and which offers a broad survey of the printed editions of the
Greek NT and does indeed describe them in the broadest sense as “editions of
the Textus Receptus.” Pastor Hixson does not, however, give proper attention to
the focus given by the Andersons at the conclusion of this article to the later
mature editions of the TR, produced by Stephanus and Beza, and especially to Scrivener’s
edition (1894), still kept in print by the TBS, as a standard representation of
the TR. Clearly, the authors of the article give greater weight to the later
Protestant editions of the TR, as opposed to earlier printed editions of the Greek
NT, which served as forerunners to it.
The Anderson article, in fact, makes the point that the term “Textus
Receptus” was not coined until the second edition of the Elzevirs in 1633.
It would be a gross misrepresentation of the Anderson
article to suggest that either the Andersons or the TBS would endorse as
legitimate any printed edition of the Greek NT that omitted Matthew 6:13b, Mark
16:9-20, John 7:53—8:11, Acts 8:37, or 1 John 5:7-8.
In the end, it is interesting to consider that even without
making a distinction between the earlier printed editions of the Greek NT and
the later classic Protestant editions of the TR, Hixson could find so few differences
among them. Even among the earliest printed editions of the Greek NT, he could
cite none that excluded the traditional ending of Mark or the PA, only one that
omitted the doxology of the Lord’s Prayer and the Ethiopian Eunuch’s confession
(the Complutensian), and only a handful that omitted the most controversial CJ
(and all those are most likely based on the first two editions of Erasmus,
later corrected by Erasmus himself).
Pastor Hixson’s study, oddly enough, actually demonstrates
how relatively uniform the printed editions of the Greek NT (whether early printed
editions or the mature Protestant TR editions) were until the nineteenth
century.
Pastor
Hixson essentially concedes as much toward the end of his post when he states, “At the end of the day, one could argue that there was eventually a consensus and
that these examples don’t actually matter.”
What he claims to take issue with is the assertion
“that TRs all agree in these ‘major’ passages, and they only
disagree in ‘minor’ places.”
He pronounces, “That claim is demonstrably
untrue—there’s just no way around it.”
Again, the problem is with Pastor Hixson’s misrepresentation
of what I meant by “printed editions of the TR.” I did not mean the Complutensian,
the first two editions of Erasmus, and Colinaeus. I meant the mature Protestant
editions of the TR produced by the Protestant orthodox, like Stephanus and
Beza. In fact, they do share a consensus on the text. They do agree in the
major passages, and generally only have minor differences. This claim is not
untrue, and there is just no way around it.
Let me deal finally with what I found to perhaps
the most interesting statement from Pastor Hixson at the end of the post. He states,
“If somebody wants to use a particular edition because textual criticism is
hard and they have a hard time evaluating modern text-critical claims but they
trust they will be safe if they use an edition that God has used for
a few hundred years, I have absolutely no problem with that.”
Pastor Hixson is essentially saying that if you
hold to the TR (“a particular edition”), you do so for three reasons:
First, “because textual criticism is hard.” In
other words, you hold to the TR, because you’re lazy.
Second, because “they have a hard time
evaluating modern text-critical claims.” In other words, you hold to the TR because
you’re dim-witted.
Third, because “they trust they will be safe
if they use an edition that God has used for a few hundred years.” In other
words, if you hold to the TR, it is because you are insecure. Notice also that
the traditional text, according to Pastor Hixson, has only been used by God “for
a few hundred years.” So, God apparently used another text (or texts) before the
TR, he used the TR for a couple hundred years, and now he’s moved on to yet
another text. If you think that God will preserve the Word and keep it pure in
all ages, it’s because you suffer from emotional insecurity.
And the last part: If you are clinging to the
wrong Bible, Pastor Hixon has “absolutely no problem with that.” His only concern
is that you “get the data right.”
So, to sum up, if you hold to the TR, you’re
lazy, dim-witted, and insecure. But if you don’t want to open your eyes, Pastor
Hixson is fine with you living in the dark.
Thank goodness we have people like Pastor Hixon
defending the modern text against those uncharitable and unenlightened “TR-Onlyists.”
I think everyone listening will join with me in
thanking Pastor Hixson for condescending to share his insights with us, to help
us “get the data right.”
JTR
Friday, December 10, 2021
The Vision (12.10.21): Fear them not
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon on Matthew 10:26-31.
Fear
ye not therefore, ye are of more value than many sparrows (Matthew 10:31).
In
Matthew 10:26-31, Christ tells his disciples three times some variation on “fear
them not” (cf. vv. 26, 28, 31). This was his historical word to the apostles,
but what is his word to us? We are not to be filled with fear as we live out
our faith and obedience to Christ.
We
are not to fear men who might slander us (v. 26):
If we
suffer insult and defamation for the cause of Christ, we are exhorted not be
filled with bitterness and resentment. We are servants who are not above our Master. We can endure all insults with patience, knowing that one day justice
will be done. One day what has been hidden will be made plain. If not in this
age, then in the age to come.
We
can, therefore, be content. We do not have the take things in our own hands. We
don’t have to set all things right. That’s not our job, but his. Consider Paul’s
words in Romans 12:19, “Dearly beloved, avenge
not yourselves, but rather give place unto wrath: for it is written, Vengeance
is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord.”
We are not to fear them which kill the body (v. 28):
Christ's words emboldened not only the original apostles but a whole line of men who came
after them, from Stephen (Acts 7) and Antipas the “faithful martyr” of Pergamos
(Revelation 2:13), to the Marian martyrs of England, to a host of modern
pastors, missionaries, and evangelists who have gladly laid down their lives
for Christ.
We
can say with Paul that for me to live is Christ, and to die is gain (Philippians
1:21). In other words, there are worse things that can happen than physical
death. Worse is spiritual death, dying apart from faith in Christ.
Finally,
we are not to fear, because just as Christ cared for the apostles, so he cares
for and governs us (v. 31).
If
the Lord so cares for the sparrows, so that not a one of them falls to the
ground apart from his will and knowledge, will he not also extend such care to
us, who are made in his image? Every hair on our head is known by him (v. 30).
It is
often the parents who know the bodies of their children best. They saw them come
into life. They bathed them and fed them and cleaned them. They know every
bend, every birthmark. Not only does a parent know her child’s body, but she
also knows the personality, spirit, and temperament.
If a
human parent knows such things about a child, how much more does our loving
heavenly Father know and care for us. Therefore, we need not fear anything.
Grace
and peace, Pastor Jeff Riddle
Thursday, December 09, 2021
2022 Kept Pure in All Ages Conference: July 22-23
I'm looking forward to the next Kept Pure in All Ages Conference in Reedsburg, Wisconsin, scheduled for Friday-Saturday, July 22-23, 2022.
JTR
Saturday, December 04, 2021
Day of Special Studies at Metropolitan Tabernacle: The War Against An Authentic Biblical Text
Monday, November 29, 2021
Saturday, November 27, 2021
Thursday, November 25, 2021
Podcast Interview (Part One) with Dwayne Green: Are You A TR Onlyist?
Saturday, November 20, 2021
WM 216: Robinson on Preservation: Part One
Friday, November 19, 2021
The Vision (11.19.21): The Priority of Preaching
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon on Matthew 10:7-15 (audio not yet posted).
And as ye go, preach,
saying the kingdom of heaven is at hand (Matthew 10:7).
In Matthew 10 Christ
sends out the twelve apostles to minister in his name. The opening words in this
“First Great Commission” are very similar to the way the “Second Great
Commission” will begin, as Christ says, “Go ye therefore and teach all nation…”
(Matthew 28:19).
The verb for “to
preach” (kerussō) means to proclaim or to herald. The content of the
preaching was, “The kingdom of heaven is at hand.” This is exactly what Christ
preached as he began his public ministry (see Matthew 4:17).
At the heart of that
message is Christ’s declaration that in his coming to this world, in the Word
being made flesh, the rule and reign of God is now a present reality.
Men who had previously
asked, “Who is God?” or “What is his will?” could now look to the man Jesus of
Nazareth and see the presence of God.
Consider the apostle
John’s words in John 1:18, “No man hath seen God
at any time, the only begotten Son, which is in the bosom of the Father, he
hath declared him.” Later in John’s Gospel, Philip will say to the Lord
Jesus, “shew us the Father, and it sufficeth us” (John 14:8), and Christ will
respond, “he that hath seen me hath seen the Father” (v. 9). The secret of
Christianity is that when you look at Jesus, you see God. When you know Jesus,
you know God. When Christ is present, God is present.
Notice also that
Christ called upon his apostles first to go and preach. This indicates
the primacy and priority of preaching.
Christ did not say to
the apostles, “And as ye go, put on dramatic performances.” He did not say,
“And was ye go, organize musical performances or multi-media presentations.” He
did not say, “And as ye go, set-up philosophy seminars, or build counseling
centers or even hospitals.” He sent the apostles out first as preachers.
In 1 Corinthians 1,
the apostle Paul will later write that “it pleased God by the foolishness of
preaching to save them that believe” (v. 21).
We are not the apostles,
but this commission to go and preach that the kingdom of heaven is at hand in
the man Jesus Christ is still our priority (cf. 2 Tim 4:1-2).
Grace and peace,
Pastor Jeff Riddle
Friday, November 12, 2021
The Vision (11.12.21): Five Observations on the Twelve Apostles
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon on Matthew 10:1-8.
Now the names of the twelve apostles are these….
(Matthew 10:2).
Let me offer at least five observations on
Matthew’s listing of the twelve (Matthew 10:2-4):
First: Though Christ had many disciples, even
thousands, who were following him, he set apart but twelve to special service
as apostles.
The number twelve had he spiritual significance (cf.
Matt 19:28). It also tells us that Christ as a true man had close friendships.
The Gospels tell us that even beyond the twelve he had a special bond with three
disciples (Peter, James, and John), and John’s Gospel tells us that perhaps his
closest friend was John himself, the beloved disciple.
This reminds us that the Christian faith is a
common faith. We are not islands. We do not go it alone. We need fellow
travelers on this journey to aid us on the way. We need fellow laborers. Many
hands make light work.
Second: Though Jesus had women disciples (followers)
during his ministry (Mary and Martha of Bethany, for example), the twelve were
all men. Only men were set apart to this extra-ordinary office, just as only
men will be set apart to the offices of elder and deacon (cf. 1 Timothy 3). Men
and women are spiritual equals before God, but they are not the same. God, in
his wisdom, requires that only qualified men service as officers.
Third: Many of these men were brothers in the flesh.
How wonderful it is when siblings share a like precious faith in the Lord.
Fourth: One of the twelve betrayed Christ. One wonders
what power was given to Judas. Did he preach sermons, cast out demons and heal
the sick in Christ’s name? This reminds us that one can have the name of disciple
and even fill an office in the church and yet be unconverted. That should make
us tremble.
Fifth: These were ordinary men whose lives were changed
by their encounter with and calling to serve Christ. They included fishermen, a
tax collector, and a political zealot.
It has often been given as a proof both for the
truth of the Christian faith and the reality of the resurrection, that these
ordinary men turned the world upside down. In Acts 4:13, Luke records the reaction
of the religious leaders to the preaching of the apostles, as they perceived “they
were unlearned and ignorant men” but “they took knowledge of them, that they
had been with Jesus.” It remains true today that when men are around Jesus,
they are transformed by him.
These men were even willing to lay down their
lives for Christ. James the son of Zebedee was the first apostle to die as a
martyr (see Acts 12:1-2). Christ himself prophesied that Peter would lay down
his life (see John 21:18-19).
You don’t lay down your life for a fairy tale or a myth, but you
will gladly lay it down for the truth of God.
Grace and peace, Pastor Jeff Riddle
Wednesday, November 10, 2021
WM 215: Review: Abidan Paul Shah, Changing the Goalpost of NT Textual Criticism
Friday, November 05, 2021
The Vision (11.5.21): The Compassion of Christ
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon on Matthew 9:36-38.
But when he saw the multitudes, he was moved with
compassion on them, because they fainted, and were scattered abroad, as sheep
having no shepherd (Matthew 9:36).
Matthew records, “he was moved with compassion on
them.” Note: He did not turn to them with annoyance, with disgust, or with
disdain, but with compassion.
That English phrase here for “he was moved with
compassion” is encompassed in just a single word in the Greek original: esplagchnithē.
This verb means to be deeply moved inwardly with compassion or pity. This is
the first of five times this verb will appear in Matthew (cf. Matt 14:14;
15:32; 18:27; 20:34).
At its root is the Greek word for the inward
parts of the persons [splagchnon]. We would say the bowls or the gut. We
might render it, “When Christ looked upon this mass of sinful and broken
humanity encompassing him, he felt for them in his gut.” The apostle Paul uses
this term several times in his letters in reference to the bowels of compassion
of Christ (see e.g., Phil 1:8; 2:1).
Matthew next provides even a further detail,
explaining the cause of Christ’s compassion:
First, “they fainted.” The verb here for “faint”
in the traditional text comes from the verb ekluō. The root means to
loose or destroy, with a prefix meaning “out from.” We could literally render
it as “worn out.” The marginal note in the Cambridge KJV suggests it could be
rendered, “were tired and lay down.” That would be something like “to
collapse.”
Second, they “were scattered abroad.” This is a
pastoral image and leads to the next description: They were “as sheep having no
shepherd.” This draws on one of the richest metaphors we have in the Scriptures
to describe the relationship between God and his people. God himself is the
Shepherd and his people are the sheep or the flock (cf. Psalm 23:1; Psalm 95:7).
Yet, these people have no pastor.
This description teaches us that Christ is not
unmoved when he looks upon a mass of sinful humanity. He feels for us and our
plight, even in the gut. He sees that we are fainting, worn out, scattered,
here, there, and yonder. And he does not leave us where we are, but he comes to
seek us till he finds us.
Those who work in various fields of human
care-giving (whether nurses, physicians, social workers, counselors, etc.) sometimes
talk about “compassion fatigue.” Minister can speak this way too. In our worst
moments, we might say something like, “This job would be great if it weren’t
for these people always bothering me.”
Think of the multitudes who surrounded Christ.
Then, consider this: Christ never experienced or experiences compassion
fatigue.
If you are a believer, when you were fainting,
disoriented, lost and scattered, Christ looked upon you with compassion and
drew you to himself. There are some of you in such a state right now upon whom
he is working, drawing you with cords of kindness.
Grace and peace, Pastor Jeff
Friday, October 29, 2021
The Vision (10.29.21): Christ Opens Blinded Eyes
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon on Matthew 9:27-35.
And when Jesus departed thence,
two blind men followed him, crying, and saying, Thou Son of David, have mercy
on us (Matthew 9:27).
And their eyes were opened
(Matthew 9:30a).
What is the significance of the
title “Son of David” which the blind men give to Christ as they call out to him
for mercy?
This title recognizes first the
fact that the Lord Jesus is, according to the flesh, a descendent of David. He
was born in Bethlehem, the city of David. He was of the house and lineage of
King David. Compare Paul’s words in Romans 1:3, “Concerning his Son Jesus Christ our Lord, which
was made of the seed of David according to the flesh.”
Underneath
this title, there is also a Messianic hope. A promise was made to David by the
Lord in 2 Samuel 7 that from his seed would come one whose kingdom and throne
would be established forever.
Later,
the prophets, especially Isaiah, also spoke about this coming king, this “anointed
one” (that’s what Messiah or Christ means) and what he would do. Compare
(emphasis added):
Isaiah
29:18 And in that day shall the deaf hear the words of the book, and the
eyes of the blind shall see out of obscurity, and out of darkness.
Isaiah
35:5 Then the eyes of the blind shall be opened, and the ears of the deaf
shall be unstopped.
And
especially Isaiah 42 which describes the servant whom Christ will send “ To open the blind eyes, to bring out the
prisoners from the prison, and them that sit in darkness out of the prison
house” (v. 7).
It is against this backdrop that
we are to understand these wretched men calling out to Christ as the Son of
David and pleading with him for mercy. It has been said that grace is when we
get what we do not deserve. And mercy is when we do not get what we do deserve.
These sinful men deserved
something far worse than blindness for their sin. They deserved death (Rom
6:23), but in crying out to the Lord Jesus as the Son of David for mercy they
were asking him to show that he is the Messiah, to demonstrate his divine mercy
toward them, by opening their blinded eyes.
In the end, Christ touched them, “And
their eyes were opened” (Matthew 9:30a). That statement can be understood in two different ways. It could
be referring to the restoration of their physical sight, but it could also be
referring to the restoration of their spiritual sight. The third option is that
it refers to both.
The
lingering question is this: What is your response to Christ? Do you believe
that he is the Christ, the Son of David, the Son of God? And believing do you
have life in his name (cf. John 20:31)?
Christ
is still opening the eyes of the spiritually blind. Psalm 146:8 says, “The LORD
openeth the eyes of the blind: the LORD raiseth them that are bowed down: the
LORD loveth the righteous.”
Are
your eyes open to see the truth of Christ?
Grace
and peace, Pastor Jeff Riddle
Friday, October 22, 2021
The Vision (10.22.21): A Father's Intercession For His Child
Note: Devotion taken from last Sunday's sermon from Matthew 9:14-26.
Matthew 9:18 While he spake these things unto them, behold, there came a certain ruler, and worshipped him, saying, My daughter is even now dead: but come and lay thy hand upon her, and she shall live. 19 And Jesus arose, and followed him, and so did his disciples.
Matthew begins, “While
he spake these things unto them, behold, there came a certain ruler….” Mark and
Luke both tell us the man’s name Jairus and that the was a “ruler of the
synagogue” (Mark 5:22; cf. Luke 8:41). He was a pious man, and a spiritual
leader.
Matthew says he
“worshipped” Christ. Here it likely means that he simply humbled himself or
bowed himself before Christ. He comes as a supplicant, a beggar. His posture relays
desperation and need. He comes not to intercede for himself but for his
precious daughter. What father would not move heaven and earth to so everything
in his power for a beloved child?
Matthew records the
father’s petition as follows: “My daughter is even now dead: but come and lay
thy hand upon her, and she shall live” (v. 18). Mark says he initially said to
the Lord, “My little daughter lieth at the point of death” (Mark 5:23). Luke
likewise reports that she “lay a dying” (Luke 8:42). How do we reconcile these
reports? I think Matthew’s record emphasizes the fact that this man knew that
if Christ did not intervene his precious daughter was as good as dead. So, he
had said, she is “even now dead.”
Both Mark and Luke
tell us the girl was twelve years of age (Mark 5:42; Luke 8:42). This means she
was on the cusp of passing from childhood to young adulthood. Luke also adds
that she was his “only daughter” (8:42). All these things add to the pathos of
the scene and help us understand the father’s great distress and desperation.
Fathers what would you
do in such circumstances for a beloved only daughter? If your child is not
gravely ill physically, what about spiritually? Would you not go to Christ on
her behalf? There is a model here for Christian fathers to follow.
Notice also the
compassion of Christ as shown by his actions in v. 19. He arises and follows
the man to his home, and his disciples come after him.
The Lord is not
indifferent to the cries of the desperate and needy. He does not put this
father off. He does not say, I’m too busy for you. Or, I have too much to do.
Here we see the love of God in Christ.
Thursday, October 21, 2021
WM 214: Text Note: Philippians 4:13
Abbreviated Notes:
I. What is the issue?
Philippians
4:13 KJV: I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me.
Philippians 4:13 ESV: I can do all things through him who strengthens me.
These
translations, of course reflect differences in text:
Philippians
4:13 Scrivener TR: παντα ισχυω εν τω ενδυναμουντι με χριστω
Philippians
4:13 WH: παντα ισχυω εν τω ενδυναμουντι με
II. External Evidence:
III. Internal Evidence:
Bruce Metzger, Textual Commentary (1994): “In order to identify who it is that strengthens Paul,
the Textus Receptus, following several of the later uncials and many
minuscules, adds Χριστῷ. If the word had been present in the original
text, there would have been no reason to omit it” (550).
Philip
Wesley Comfort, A Commentary on Textual Additions to the New Testament
(Kregel, 2017) says the inclusion of “Christ” came about as the result of “scribal
gap-filling wherein a scribe was influenced by 1 Timothy 1:12” (122).
Questions:
Would scribe copying Philippians have been influenced by a disconnected passage from 1 Timothy?
If a scribe added “Christ” to harmonize with 1 Timothy 1:12 why did he add only “Christ.” Why did he not add, “Christ Jesus our Lord”?
If “Christ” was original why would a scribe have omitted it?
Accidental Omission.
Intentional Omission.
IV. Conclusions:
Michael Horton, The Christian Faith: A Systematic Theology for Pilgrims on the Way (Zondervan, 2011), regarding Christology: "The liberal trajectory leading from Reimarus’ Fragments to D. F. Strauss’s Life of Jesus and Adolf von Harnack’s Essence of Christianity is essentially Arian (or “Adoptionist”). 'The Gospel as Jesus preached it, has to do with the Father only and not with the Son,' Harnack declared" (464-465).
In the
end, I see no reason to justify the abandonment of the traditional text of
Philippians 4:13 and many reasons to reaffirm it.
JTR


