Showing posts with label Hegesippus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hegesippus. Show all posts

Monday, October 14, 2019

Eusebius, EH.4.19-22: Hegesippus and the "Seven Heresies"



This is an occasional series of readings from and brief notes and commentary upon Eusebius of Caesarea’s The Ecclesiastical History. Here is Book 4, chapters 19-22. Listen here.

Notes and Commentary:

These chapters continue the record of the succession of church leaders in various cities during the reign of Marcus Aurelius, as well as cataloguing the various heresies that contended with the orthodox faith. Special attention is given to the early Jewish Christian writer Hegessipus.

Chapters 19-20 notes that in Rome Soter succeeded Anicetus; in Alexandria, Agrippinus succeeded Celadion; in Antioch Theophilus (sixth from the apostles) succeeded Eros (fifth) who succeeded Cornelius (fourth).

Chapter 21 notes other key writers and leaders who provided a standard for ‘sound faith”, including Hegessipus, Dionysius of Corinth, Pinytus of Crete, as well as Philip, Apolinarius, Melito, Musanus, Modestus, and “above all” Irenaeus.

Chapter 22 turns to the writings of Hegesippus, who, Eusebius says, wrote five treatises. He also says that Hegesippus was “converted from among the Hebrews.”

Eusebius cites Hegesippus as saying he had traveled widely, as far as Rome, and that he had “mingled” with many key bishops “and that he found the same doctrine among them all.”

He adds Hegesippus’s observation that in each city “things are as the law, the prophets, and the Lord preach.”

He further notes Hegesippus’s record of the bishops in Jerusalem where Simeon followed James the Just and his claim that the earliest church was like a “virgin” before the rise of heresies.

He notes one source of error as Thebouthis who was not made a bishop and says this began the “seven heresies” (but it is hard to say what these seven were, since more than seven seem to be listed). The various heresies catalogued include:

Simon (Magus) and the Simonians;
Cleobius and the Cleobians;
Dositheus and the Dosthians;
Gorthaeus and the Goratheni and the Masbothei;
The Menandrianists, Marcianists, Carpocratians, Valentinians, Basilidians, and Saturnillians.

To these he adds a list of (seven) Jewish sects: Essenes, Galileans, Hemerobaptists, Masbothei, Samaritans, Sadducees, and Pharisees.

He adds a few further observations on Hegesippus’s writings noting that they included extracts from the Gospel according to the Hebrews and that he discussed various apocryphal writings.

Conclusion:

Eusebius again sees a pristine early church, attacked from within by various heresies, withstood by the line of faithful bishops and orthodox writers, like Hegesippus.

JTR

Tuesday, September 24, 2019

Eusebius, EH.4.8-9: Hegesippus, Justin & Hadrian's Letter



This is an occasional series of readings from and brief notes and commentary upon Eusebius of Caesarea’s The Ecclesiastical History. Here is Book 4, chapters 8-9. Listen here.

Notes and Commentary:

In these chapters Eusebius continues the sentiment begun at the end of the previous chapter by describing the “champions” who defended the faith, especially in writing.

Chapter 8 begins with mention of Hegesippus who composed five books “giving in the simplest style of writing the unerring tradition of the apostolic preaching.”

He notes, in particular, Hegesippus’s criticism of Roman idolatry, citing a shrine set up for worship of Antinous a favorite slave of Hadrian.

Next, he recalls how Justin Martyr also criticized this idolatry in his Apology to Antoninus.

He also notes Justin’s record of the Bar-Cochba revolt and the persecution of Christians at this time. Eusebius also Justin’s conversion to the faith from Platonic philosophy, noting that this change came about by his reasoned judgment.

Furthermore, he notes Justin’s record of persecution during the time of Hadrian and how a governor Serrenius Granianus wrote to the emperor urging that Christians not be treated unjustly.

Eusebius also includes Justin’s account of Hadrian writing to Minucius Fundanus, proconsul of Asia, urging fair treatment of Christians.

In chapter 9 Eusebius cites Hadrian’s letter (from Justin), which, Eusebius says, he translated from Latin to Greek. The letter ends with the emperor telling the proconsul that if anyone brings charges against Christians “for the purpose of blackmail” to “investigate strenuously and be careful to inflict penalties adequate to the crime.”

Conclusion:

These chapters describe the ministries of the apologists Hegesippus and Justin and the ways in which Christians responded to persecution during Hadrian’s reign. According to Eusebius the Christians were beginning to gain sympathy from the Romans at the highest levels of government. This shows how the Christian movement was growing and appearing of the radar in Roman society.

JTR

Wednesday, July 24, 2019

Eusebius, EH.3.17-20: Domitian, Persecution, and the Grand-Nephews of Jesus



Image: Closeup of marble bust of Domitian (AD 51-96), Louvre Museum, Paris

New episode posted to the series on Eusebius of Caesarea’s The Ecclesiastical History: Book 3, chapters 17-20. Listen here.

Notes and Commentary:

These chapters cover various developments in early Christianity during the reign of the Roman Emperor Domitian (or Domitianus, 51-96; emperor, 81-96).

Chapter 17: Eusebius notes Domitian’s great cruelty against his fellow Romans. He was “the successor to Nero’s campaign of hostility to God” and, following after Nero, was the second to promote persecution of Christians.

Chapter 18: John the Apostle and Evangelist was exiled to Patmos at this time. Note: Eusebius assumes John the Apostle is the author of Revelation. He also cites Irenaeus as saying John wrote Revelation during Domitian’s reign.

He notes that in the 15th year of Domitian’s reign, Flavia Domitilla, niece of the Romans consul Flavius Clemens and other Christians were banished to the island of Pontia. If true, this shows the spread of Christianity to high social circles in Rome.

Chapters 19-20: Eusebius relays a tradition from Hegesippus that the grandsons of Jesus’s brother Judas [Jesus’s grand-nephews] were threatened by Domitian, since they came from the family of David. They are described as relatively poor laborers [farmers? See Richard J. Bauckham] and small landholders [39 plethra; Lake suggests that a plethron was about one fourth of an acre; so, 39 plethra would be less than 10 acres]. They were released by Domitian and became leaders in the church.

He cites Tertullian’s statement that Domitian was “a Nero in cruelty.”

Domitian was succeeded by Nerva.

Eusebius closes by noting that after his banishment John settled in Ephesus.

JTR